My new book project

The Case of the Murderous Doctor Cream

The Birth of Sherlock Holmes and the Hunt for the Serial Killer

Who Terrorized Chicago and London  

by Dean Jobb

 

To be published by Algonquin Books in the U.S. and HarperCollins Canada

“When a doctor goes wrong, he is the first of criminals,” Sherlock Holmes observed during one of his most puzzling investigations. “He has nerve and he has knowledge.” Incredibly, as the words of the world’s most famous fictional detective appeared in print in The Strand magazine in the early 1890s, a Scottish-born Canadian doctor was preying on women in London’s downtrodden Lambeth neighborhood. Thomas Neill Cream – the "Lambeth Poisoner," as he was dubbed in the press – killed at least nine people in three countries, a murderous spree that eclipsed the crimes of the notorious Jack the Ripper.

Thomas Neill Cream as a medical student in 1870s Montreal. Photo: McCord Museum

Thomas Neill Cream as a medical student in 1870s Montreal. Photo: McCord Museum

The Case of the Murderous Doctor Cream will chronicle the hunt for a Victorian-era monster and expose, for the first time, the failure of police and justice officials in the United States, Canada and Britain to identify and stop one of the world’s first serial killers. Cream, the son of a wealthy Quebec City timber merchant, earned a medical degree from Montreal's McGill University in 1876 and immediately employed his "nerve and knowledge" to lethal effect. His first victim was likely a woman in Waterloo, Quebec, who fell ill shortly after their marriage that year. Suspected of killing a female patient in London, Ontario in 1879, he fled to Chicago, where he murdered three more women before he was convicted of poisoning his lover’s husband. After serving ten years in an Illinois prison, Cream was set free in 1891 – and unleashed his wrath on the prostitutes of London. To the Chicago Tribune, it was a case “without parallel in the annals of English criminal jurisprudence” and marked the emergence of a new breed of killer, one who operated without motive or remorse, who “murdered simply for the sake of murder.” 

One of Cream's patients died after he performed an abortion in Chicago in 1880. He was charged with her murder but acquitted at trial. Source: Chicago Daily News, August 23, 1880

One of Cream's patients died after he performed an abortion in Chicago in 1880. He was charged with her murder but acquitted at trial. Source: Chicago Daily News, August 23, 1880

This dark tale of murder and madness, flawed detection and official indifference will be told in tandem with Arthur Conan Doyle’s creation of Sherlock Holmes, the iconic sleuth who transformed crime fiction. (In a remarkable coincidence, Doyle was studying medicine in Edinburgh in 1878, the year the university granted Cream a licence to practise as a physician.) Cream’s rampage was “murder on almost a wholesale scale ... an Elizabethan tragedy of horrors,” in the words of one writer. It coincided with the birth of modern forensic science and an explosion of interest in tales of crime and detection. “Detective-fever,” an observer noted, “engulfed the Victorian reading public.” Fact mirrored fiction as Doyle’s detective methodically solved crimes on the page while police on two continents struggled to link a string of seemingly random killings to a single, mysterious suspect.

Daniel Stott's grave marker in the northern Illinois hamlet of Garden Prairie records Cream's conviction for his murder in 1881. The doctor served 10 years in Joliet prison before being freed to kill again. Photo: Dean Jobb

Daniel Stott's grave marker in the northern Illinois hamlet of Garden Prairie records Cream's conviction for his murder in 1881. The doctor served 10 years in Joliet prison before being freed to kill again. Photo: Dean Jobb

The Case of the Murderous Doctor Cream will take readers on a journey through Canada and the U.S. and on to 1890s London, on the trail of one of history's earliest and most callous serial killers. It is the first book to tell the full story of Cream's outrageous crimes, the role Canadian and American authorities played in freeing him to kill again, and Scotland Yard's desperate search for a cold-blooded murderer as brazen as his predecessor, Jack the Ripper. And it will bring to life a forgotten story of murder and suspense, recreating a lost world where evil lurked on the gas-lit streets of Chicago and London.

 

Check this site for updates on my research and publication details

 

A stereoscope view of traffic-clogged Ludgate Circus in 1892. Cream frequented The King Lud public house, on the left side of the image, as he preyed on London's prostitutes. Photo: Author collection

A stereoscope view of traffic-clogged Ludgate Circus in 1892. Cream frequented The King Lud public house, on the left side of the image, as he preyed on London's prostitutes. Photo: Author collection